Durruti: a worker in the revolution
Buenaventura Durruti died in Madrid on 20 November 1936. He had arrived with part of his column to help defend the city against the fascist advance. A worker and an anarchist CNT activist, he embodied a current that linked the anti-fascist struggle to social transformation. CNT Madrid.
He belonged to a movement of unions, workers’ cultural centres, activists and working-class communities. Libertarian communism had a project for society: at its Zaragoza Congress in May 1936, the CNT advocated collective ownership, workers’ management and the federation of free communes. Anselmo Lorenzo Foundation.
What they share: ending exploitation
Anarchism encompasses different currents. Here we are discussing the libertarian communism and anarcho-syndicalism associated with Durruti’s world. Comparing them with Marxism-Leninism requires distinguishing them from individualism and the capitalist defence of the market.
Both traditions seek to overcome a society where one class controls the means of production and another must sell its labour to survive. They share the aspiration to a classless, stateless society. Freedom requires access to the means of life: people dependent on an owner for food or work have little control over their existence. Malatesta linked economic emancipation with political emancipation; Lenin placed the disappearance of the state after the overcoming of class divisions. Malatesta and Lenin.
The major difference: the state and the transition
For Marxism-Leninism, overthrowing the bourgeoisie does not immediately eliminate its capacity to resist. The revolution needs workers’ power to transform ownership, coordinate the economy and defend its gains. In this theory, the “dictatorship of the proletariat” means the political rule of the working class during that transition.
Nor did Lenin propose simply taking over the existing state intact. In The State and Revolution, he argued for destroying the bourgeois bureaucratic and military machine and replacing it with institutions of workers’ power. Drawing on the Paris Commune, he advocated elected and recallable representatives and limits on their pay. The stated aim was to prevent administration from becoming separated from the population. Lenin, Chapters III and VI.
The anarchist objection challenges precisely that separation: what prevents those administering power from eventually defending it against the workers themselves? Bakunin warned that a government made up of former workers could develop interests different from those of people who continued to work. This critique of concentrated power predated the existence of the USSR. Bakunin, Statism and Anarchy.
Organisation, party and self-management
Leninism assigns the vanguard party a role in political organisation, strategic development and the coordination of struggles that might otherwise remain isolated. In What Is to Be Done?, written under the tsarist autocracy, Lenin argued for a revolutionary organisation capable of sustaining activity against repression and overcoming local fragmentation. Lenin, 1902.
Libertarian communism proposes organising production and collective life through associations, unions, communes and federations. Rejecting the state does not mean rejecting agreements, responsibilities or coordination. Malatesta insisted that acting in isolation wastes strength and weakens the oppressed. The debate concerns how to organise without consolidating an authority that imposes itself on the members. Malatesta, Anarchism and Organization.
Nor can a decree abolish the need to supply cities, maintain transport or defend a revolution. The disagreement concerns which institutions undertake those tasks and who effectively controls them.
When ideas meet war
In 1936, workers in Catalonia took over the management of collectivised factories, workshops and services. Those experiences demonstrated workers’ organisational capacities while coexisting with republican institutions, shortages and military needs. Conflict over who controlled production and weapons had immediate consequences. Barcelona Provincial Council.
Decisions did not always follow programmes either. In November 1936, four CNT activists entered Largo Caballero’s government, including Federica Montseny. Participation in government provoked intense debate within the anarchist movement. Federica Montseny Centre.
After Durruti’s death, tensions erupted in the May 1937 clashes in Barcelona. Government forces, communists, anarchists and members of the POUM, a Marxist organisation opposed to Stalinism, were involved. Reducing this to “anarchists against Marxists” erases decisive actors and conflicts over war and revolution. Barcelona Provincial Council.
Freedom also needs material means
The comparison raises two inseparable demands: transforming the material conditions of life and preventing the instruments of emancipation from turning against their protagonists.
The libertarian challenge is to sustain coordination, supplies and defence without a separate state power. The Marxist-Leninist challenge is to ensure that power proclaimed to be workers’ power remains effectively under the control of those who work. The names of institutions do not settle those questions.
Remembering Durruti means taking that revolutionary ambition seriously: that the people who produce wealth should be able to decide how to live.


